篇名 | 柏拉圖如何在《巴門尼德篇》第一部分展示早中期「理念論」的困難及其解決方案 |
---|---|
卷期 | 47:4=551 |
並列篇名 | The Difficulties of and the Solution to Plato’s Early and Mid-term Theory of Idea in the First Part of the Parmenides |
作者 | 劉鑫 |
頁次 | 163-179 |
關鍵字 | 柏拉圖 、 理念 、 分有 、 謂述 、 模仿 、 製造 、 Plato 、 Idea 、 Participation 、 Predication 、 Imitation 、 Production 、 A&HCI |
出刊日期 | 202004 |
本文以柏拉圖《巴門尼德篇》第一部分為研究對象,分析其中理念論所面臨的六個詰難。在此基礎上得出結論:柏拉圖的批評並非要取消或者消解理念論,而是要展示早中期理念論所面臨的困難。不僅如此,柏拉圖在批評中已經隱含地給出了解決問題的方案,本文將徹底澄清這一點,給六個詰難一個一以貫之的解答。
In this paper, I take the first part of Plato’s dialogue Parmenides as subject matter, analysing the six aporiai which Plato’s theory of idea probably leads to. Based on the detailed text analysis, I draw a conclusion that Plato’s criticism does not aim to abolish his theory of idea, but Plato is inclined to illuminate the problems that arise from his early and mid-term dialogues. In addition, I argue that Plato implies as well as gives solutions to the problems mentioned in his criticism. In closing, I provide a consistent solution to all of the six aporiai.