篇名 | 呼氣一氧化碳測量儀評估年輕軍人吸菸習慣之準確性分析 |
---|---|
卷期 | 17:4 |
並列篇名 | The diagnostic accuracy of carbon monoxide breathalyzer(COB) in assessing smoking habits of young soldiers |
作者 | 林祖佑 、 佘振興 、 程文祺 、 魯子全 、 陳聲平 、 洪淵庭 |
頁次 | 279-288 |
關鍵字 | 呼氣一氧化碳測量儀 、 吸菸習慣 、 ROC曲線 、 切點值 、 carbon monoxide breathalyzer 、 smoking habits 、 ROC curve 、 cut-off level 、 TSCI |
出刊日期 | 201010 |
目的與背景: 實務上針對年輕軍人使用呼氣一氧化碳測量儀(carbon monoxide
breathalyzer,COB)時,常參考廠商建議的最佳檢驗切點值(optimal cut-off level)來評估吸煙習慣,偶爾會出現數據與真實習慣不符的情形。因此本研究透過對年輕軍人吸煙習慣的檢
測,探討適用之最佳檢驗切點值,並對準確性作驗證與分析,以提供較正確有力之依據,亦有利後續戒菸之追蹤評估。方法:利用軍營戒菸宣導活動,採「立意取樣」對來自台灣各營區的軍人共117位,實施問卷調查並以COB檢測每人之呼氣ㄧ氧化碳濃度。吸煙習慣之黃金診斷標準以問卷中回答每日吸菸量小於10支者,定義為”A組”,大於10支者為”B組”;分別以0-10 ppm為檢驗切點,計算各點所具有之敏感度及專一度,並以ROC曲線(receiver operating characteristic curve)進行準確性分析。結果:問卷結果分為A組31人,B組86人;樣本全體平均年齡25.2±6.2歲;呼氣一氧化碳平均值,樣本全體:12.6±10.8 ppm,A組:3.3±2.2
ppm,B組:16.0±10.1 ppm,達明顯統計差異(p<0.001)。最佳檢驗切點值顯示為6 ppm,其敏
感度86%,專一度94%,陽性相似比(positive likelihood ratio,LR+):13.3。ROC曲線下面積(area under curve,AUC)為0.923(95%信賴區間:0.86-0.985)。結論:運用ROC曲線分析,得知呼氣一氧化碳濃度在本研究中,區分兩種吸菸習慣的最佳檢驗切點值應為6 ppm,也再次驗證COB仍是評估年輕軍人吸煙習慣之優良診斷工具。
Background: The optimal cut-off level recommended by manufacturers of carbon monoxide breathalyzer(COB) is often adopted in soldiers’smoking cessation; however, the data obtained doesn’t always correspond to the real smoking habits.This research aimed at evaluating the optimal cut-off level of COB and further analyzing its accuracy when assesseing smoking
habit in young soldiers, which shall offer a more reliable basis for following programs.Methods: Self-reported questionnaires and exhaled carbon monoxide(CO) detection by COB were performed by 117 soldiers from various camps all over Taiwan. Based on the self-reported smoking status, soldiers who smoked less than 10 cigarettes a day were defined as “Group A”, while more than 10 cigarettes as“Group B”.Under this gold standard, 0-10 ppm of carbon monoxide concentration was taken as cut-off level and the sensitivity, specificity of each level was calculated.The diagnostic accuracy was analysed with receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve.
Results: Of the total population (average age 25.2±6.2 years), 31 and 86 subjects were classified to Group A and B,respectively.The mean value of exhaled CO was 12.6±10.8 ppm,constituted by Group A at 3.3±2.2 ppm and Group B at 16.0±10.1 ppm(p<0.001). The optimal cut-off level was 6 ppm with a sensitivity of 86%, specificity of 94% and positive likelihood ratio(LR+) as 13.3. The area under ROC curve(AUC) was 0.923(95%C.I.=0.860-0.985).Conclusion: After the analysis of ROC curve, we found that 6 ppm should be the optimal cut-off level of exhaled CO for distinguishing between two smoking habits in our population and that COB is still an excellent diagnostic tool for assessing smoking habits in young soldiers.