文章詳目資料

地理學報 CSSCIScopusTSSCI

  • 加入收藏
  • 下載文章
篇名 全球化時代的文化遺產古蹟保存理論之批判性回顧
卷期 42
並列篇名 Cultural Heritage in the Age of Globalization A Critical Review of Historic Preservation Theories
作者 顏亮一
頁次 001-024
關鍵字 cultural heritagehistoric preservationglobalizationheterotopiaTaiwan Provincial Leprosarium文化遺產古蹟保存全球化異質地方樂生療養院ScopusTSSCI
出刊日期 200512

中文摘要

古蹟保存作為歷史、傳統、與記憶在營造環境中的一種再現方式,長久以來 都被用來界定特定在地社群的集體時空想像。保存的對象暗示了「想像社群」之 集體文化認同,而以視覺的方式來訴說該社群的歷史,強化該社群成員對自己身 份的共識。從這個角度來看,古蹟保存的功能往往具有高度的政治性。然而,當 前經濟與文化全球化的持續進行,使得各地方之間的互動與依賴不斷地強化,而 不同想像社群之間的界線似乎也越來越模糊了。如果說古蹟保存是一個與地方社 群認同密切相關的事業,那麼在一個地方界線逐漸模糊的年代,古蹟保存的意義 會是什麼?而就在這個全球化似乎即將泯滅各個地方特殊文化與認同的世紀之 交,臺灣才正要開始建立古蹟保存的價值、論述、與制度,我們如何理解這個特 別的現象?在今天的全球化情境下,我們的古蹟保存大計又應建立在什麼樣的理 論基礎上?它可能的社會與政治意義為何?它與都市發展的關係為何?基於對 臺灣社會與空間現實的關切下,本文試圖發展一個分析全球化情境中古蹟保存政 治過程的初步理論架構,希望能作為研究臺灣本地古蹟保存經驗以及擬定政策與 運動方向的基礎。本文批判性地回顧了以下三個相關理論:第一、全球化情境與 古蹟保存之間的關係;第二、古蹟保存與現代性的發展;第三、由法國理論家 Michel Foucault 所提出的「異質地方」概念。最後,經過對上述諸理論的回顧與 重組後,本文將以樂生療養院保存運動作為分析對象,提出幾點對於臺灣當前古 蹟保存政治的初步看法。

英文摘要

Historic preservation, the representation of the past, memories and traditions in the built environment, has long been an important planning instrument for defining the collective imagination of time and space of communities ranging in size from countries, to regions, to cities, to neighborhoods. The preserved objects usually imply the cultural identity of the “imagined community” and precisely who actually belongs to this community. In this sense, the function of historic preservation has been highly political and complex. However, the ongoing process of economic and cultural globalization has further complicated the politic of historic preservation in the contemporary world. As the interactions and interdependence between distant places increasingly become intensified, the boundaries between different imagined communities have gradually blurred. If historic preservation has historically been an enterprise relating to the formation of place identity, what are the possible meanings of historic preservation in an age in which boundaries between places are increasingly blurring? What are the relations between historic preservation and urban development in the era of globalization? What is the theoretical foundation for historic preservation projects of Taiwan, where the enterprise of historic preservation is just burgeoning? Bearing in mind the development of Taiwan’s historic preservation policies and movements, I attempt to construct a theoretical framework that can better our understanding of contemporary politic of historic preservation in the globalizing cities. I have drawn upon three distinct literatures to build such a theoretical framework: 1. the debates of the functions of historic preservation in global cities; 2. the theories of the relations between historic preservation and modernity; 3. the concept of “heterotopia” coined by Michel Foucault. Finally, using the conceptual framework developed in this research, I have studied the preservation movement of Taiwan Provincial Leprosarium and offer some preliminary suggestions for the contemporary preservation politics in Taiwan.

相關文獻